When most people picture insulation, they picture batts. Pink or yellow rectangles pushed between joists. It is what we have all seen, and for a lot of situations it does a perfectly good job. So why does spray foam cost more, and is that difference actually worth it?
The honest answer is that they are not really the same product doing the same job. Comparing them on price alone usually means missing what each one actually does.
Filling versus sealing
Batts fill the spaces between framing. They rely on a snug fit and on staying put over time. The moment a batt sags, gaps a little, or was cut slightly short, air moves around it. Draughts, by definition, happen in the gaps.
Spray foam is sprayed on as a liquid and expands to fill every void it touches. It adheres to the substrate and forms a continuous layer. There are no gaps to draught through because the gap was filled as part of the application.
What that difference means over time
- Spray foam adheres permanently and will not sag or fall out, so the performance you get on day one is the performance you get years later.
- Closed cell foam acts as a moisture barrier and is mould resistant, where batts can hold moisture and be susceptible to damage.
- Closed cell foam is difficult for rodents to gnaw, unlike fibreglass batts which make ideal nesting material.
- Because it is sprayed, foam conforms to complex shapes, which is ideal for architecturally intricate homes where batts are hard to fit cleanly.
When batts are perfectly fine
We are not here to talk down other options. Every insulation has its place, and for some applications a well installed batt does exactly what is needed at a lower cost. The point is not that batts are bad. It is that spray foam is solving a different problem: sealing the building, not just filling the gaps between framing.
If you are deciding between the two, the question to ask is what you are actually trying to fix. If it is draughts, cold floors, or a house that never holds its temperature, the sealing is usually what matters most.
Tell us what your home is doing and we will give you a straight answer on whether batts, foam, or a combination is the right move for your place.
Want honest advice for your place?
Tell us about your property and we will help you understand whether spray foam is the right fit, with no pressure and no obligation.



